Glendon Campus
York University
2275 Bayview Avenue
Toronto, Ontario
Canada M4N 3M6
Globe takes Layton to task, citing Glendon historian Michiel Horn


You can't libel the dead – but you can disparage them, wrote The Globe and Mail Oct. 10. In the most demagogic moment of the federal election campaign, NDP Leader Jack Layton (left) erroneously compared Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper with R.B. Bennett, the Conservative prime minister during the Great Depression (1930-1935).

As historian Michiel Horn (right), professor emeritus at York’s Glendon College, observed in the Globe only a week ago, "the wily and able" [Liberal prime minister] Mackenzie King seriously misjudged the first months of the Depression. "Unemployment was rising but it always rose in the winter," Horn noted. "Periodic downturns in the business cycle were familiar events. [King] faced the election without fear." King was "unconcerned." Bennett, on the other hand, called the Depression "the great dark days" of Canadian history, wrote the Globe. He won the election with his promise "to take whatever action is necessary to end [unemployment] or to perish in the attempt."

From the October 14th edition of York University’s Y File

Published on October 14, 2008